Remodel vs. New Build: The Dishroom Decision Guide

The Most Common Misjudgments We See

Operators frequently underestimate:

• The true cost of retrofitting utilities
• How new dish machine loads affect the building
• When “just replacing the machine” triggers a full code update
• The labor impact of undersized equipment
• How long ROI actually takes on upgrades

These misjudgments lead to:

• Failed inspections
• Chronic downtime
• Budget overruns
• And equipment that never performs at capacity

‍

When a Simple Replacement Still Works

You can usually replace the dish machine only (no remodel) if all of the following are true:

• Electrical capacity already matches the new machine
• Hot water supply meets flow and temperature requirements
• Drainage, air gaps, and grease interception are code-compliant
• Existing hood and ventilation are correctly sized
• No change in machine type (e.g., door-type to conveyor)
• The room was built to commercial dishroom standards originally

If all six conditions are met, a straight replacement is often safe and cost-effective.

‍

Red Flags That Mean “Don’t Patch This”

If you see any of the following, a patch-and-replace approach usually fails:

• Chronic drain backups or floor flooding
• Undersized electrical panels with no spare capacity
• No indirect waste with proper air gap
• Improvised venting or hood tie-ins
• Repeated heat or chemical sanitizer violations
• Structural floors not rated for conveyor or flight machines
• Low ceiling clearance that traps steam
• No space for proper clean/dirty separation

These are signals that the infrastructure—not the machine—is the real problem.

‍

Utility Limits That Force a Full Remodel

A full remodel becomes unavoidable when:

• Electrical capacity cannot support:
  
  • Booster heaters
  • Large conveyor motors

• Plumbing supply cannot maintain:
  
  • Continuous 180°F final rinse (high-temp)
  • Adequate gallons per minute (GPM)

• Drainage systems lack:
  
  • Indirect waste
  • Air gaps
  • Slope to floor sinks

• Ventilation systems cannot:
  
  • Capture steam load
  • Maintain room pressure balance

At that point, installing a new machine without rebuilding utilities usually leads to immediate failures.

When Adding a Conveyor Breaks the Building

Switching from:

• Undercounter → Door-Type
• Door-Type → Conveyor
• Conveyor → Flight-Type

Is not just an equipment swap. It can trigger:

• Structural reinforcement
• New hood systems
• Additional make-up air
• Electrical service upgrades
• Drain trenching
• Grease interceptor resizing

In many older buildings, the building simply cannot physically support continuous conveyor operations without reconstruction.

The Hidden Cost of “Just Make It Work”

Failing to remodel when needed leads to:

• Higher labor costs
• Rewash rates
• Chemical overuse
• Heat stress on staff
• Equipment failures
• Energy waste
• Inspection citations
• Unplanned shutdowns

Over 5 years, these losses frequently exceed the cost of a proper remodel.

Bottom Line

• If the utilities, structure, and ventilation already match your production goals → replace the machine.
• If the infrastructure is limiting performance or compliance → remodel.
• If your menu volume and staffing model have fundamentally changed → rebuild.

The wrong choice can cost you twice—once in construction and again in ongoing inefficiency.

Replace vs. Remodel vs. Rebuild: Dishroom Decision Comparison Chart

‍

What Typically Triggers Each Path

Replace is usually right when:

• Utilities already meet manufacturer specs
• Hood and ventilation are properly sized
• No change in machine type (e.g., door → door)
• Drainage and air gaps are compliant
• Throughput demand is staying the same

‍

Remodel is usually required when:

• Electrical service needs upgrading for booster heaters
• Drainage requires trenching or air gap correction
• Hood needs resizing or steam capture correction
• Layout needs better clean/dirty separation
• Staffing flow is inefficient

‍

Rebuild is usually unavoidable when:

• Converting to conveyor or flight-type systems
• Structural floors won’t support continuous machine loads
• Ceiling heights trap steam
• Utilities are undersized across all systems
• Repeated inspection failures continue after repairs
• Production volume has doubled or tripled

‍

The Cost of Choosing the Wrong Path

‍

Quick Rule of Thumb

• If utilities and ventilation already meet the new machine’s requirements → Replace. ‍
• If one or two systems are limiting performance → Remodel. ‍
• If three or more core systems are failing (power, water, drain, hood, structure) → Rebuild.